|
Published: September 30, 2009
Pundits greeted Angela Merkel’s convincing
election win in Germany Sunday with a collective yawn.
Commentators think the German economy is sluggish and
over-dependent on exports, and believe that a change in the
German government from a grand coalition to a center-right
coalition will make little policy difference.
I think that’s wrong. It’s an erroneous viewpoint that’s
symptomatic of the short memories of the chattering media. It’s
also one that could cause investors to miss out on one of the
best profit plays in the global marketplace today.
I’m talking about Germany -- the real powerhouse of Europe.
The “New” Germany
From the 1950s to the 1980s, West Germany consistently
delivered high growth rates and low inflation. West German
engineering proved superior to any other on the planet. And West
German living standards rose far above anywhere else in Europe.
Then came 1990.
East and West Germany were reunited and an economic malaise set
in. Instead of unifying the two currencies at a ratio of two
Ostmarks to one Deutsche Mark, which would have kept East German
labor cheap and competitive, the politicians unified the
currencies at a rate of one to one.
That meant that East German labor was instantly priced out of
the world market. And with good reason: It now offered
Soviet-sector efficiency and skill -- but at West German costs
levels. Consequently, East Germany went through more than a
decade of very high unemployment. German taxpayers went through
more than a decade of huge subsidies to the former East Germany
to prop up that region’s living standards and retrain its labor.
However, since the excellent German high school education system
was quickly established throughout the country, the burden of
reunification was a problem that did not last forever. What
ultimately happened was that younger, fully trained workers in
East Germany replaced their inferior Communist-era parents.
From about 2005 onward, the
financial cloud of reunification
costs began to lift. During the last
few years, Germany’s economic
performance has been notably better
than its European competitors.
Against Italy alone, for example,
Germany’s competitiveness has
improved by more than +20% since
Europe’s currencies were unified in
1999.
The German economy has been held
down by a tax burden that’s high by
global standards. Its tax system
suffers from excessive complexity
and from draconian enforcement.
Small businesses, for example must
pay a 14% trade tax -- on top of the
standard corporate income tax that
all businesses must pay. The trade
tax goes to the “lander” (the
states), rather than to the federal
government.
Despite such problems, Germany has
played it smart in several key
areas. Unlike the United States and
many other countries, Germany did
not engage in fiscal stimulus.
Indeed, the Social Democrat Finance
Minister Peer Steinbruck last winter
referred to Britain’s huge fiscal
stimulus plans as “crass
Keynesianism.” That showed that
Germany has a true consensus against
the stimulus foolishness. Germany’s
budget deficit is expected by The
Economist panel of forecasters
to be only 4.6% of GDP in 2009, far
below its rich-country competitors.
Thus, even though Germany’s taxes
are high, they will not be forced
further upwards by zooming budget
deficits. The Angela Merkel Era
Begins
Merkel’s election as German Chancellor is important, because it
enables her to govern in coalition with the most free-market
party, the Free Democrats, who are committed to lowering taxes
and freeing up some of Germany’s restrictive labor laws.
This should not be taken too far. The Free Democrat leader Guido
Westerwelle, flushed with victory, pledged Sunday night that the
new government would act “responsibly” -- not exactly “Hope and
Change” as a slogan! Nevertheless, the Frankfurt market rose on
the election result, as it should have done.
Germany is sometimes knocked for its export orientation. Its
balance-of-payments surplus was $179.4 billion for the fiscal
year that ended June 30, and is expected to be 4.0% of GDP this
year.
Rest assured, however, that this is strength, and not a
weakness. With world trade recovering, the German economy can be
expected to benefit. Just look at Germany’s auto sector, which
may be the most well rounded in the world. It boasts such strong
luxury brands as Mercedes (NYSE ADR: DAI), Porsche and
Audi. And it includes such high-volume -- but innovative --
manufacturers as Volkswagen AG (OTC ADR: VLKAY). German
automakers are likely to gain market share against faltering
U.S. competitors in the coming global recovery.
Another plus: Germany’s savings rate rose to 12.8% of GDP in the
first half of 2009, a 16-year record. That compares with the
feeble rate of only 4% in the United States, up from close to
zero in the preceding three years. In a competitive world with
the financial sector in difficulty, it’s better to be a
capital-rich country running a trade surplus than the opposite,
like the United States.
The economic recovery is a mixed bag from one market to another.
But in Germany, it seems to be proceeding briskly. GDP, which
fell sharply in the first quarter, rose at a 1.3% annual rate in
the second quarter. Manufacturing orders rose by +3.5% in July,
after a +3.8% rise in June. The ZEW index of economic sentiment
has risen in each of the last six months, reaching a healthy
57.7 (50 is neutral) in September.
With competitive manufacturing, a business-friendly government
and plenty of domestic capital, Germany is about as healthy an
economy as there is in the world today. You should think about
staking a claim to this outlook, even if it’s only the MSCI
Germany Exchange-Traded Fund (NYSE: EWG).
-- Martin Hutchinson
Contributing Writer
Money Morning |