|
Published: March 4, 2010
Less than a month ago
I told you about what amounted to a rule change at the
Environmental Protection Agency (EPA). The Obama administration
adjusted an output timetable for the production of cellulosic
ethanol, an advanced biofuel.
Now, if you didn't hear this gripping news from me, you probably
didn't hear about it. It's inside baseball for environmental
wonks. The nation's Page One editors did not scramble to
redesign the covers of their newspapers to make room for the
story.
But that doesn’t mean that it's not vital.
First, a little background.
Ethanol, or ethyl alcohol, is pure alcohol typically fermented
from the starches in corn that can be blended with gasoline to
make motor vehicle fuel. Henry Ford's first car, in fact, ran on
the stuff. Today, though most cars use fossil-fuel based
gasoline, federal law nevertheless calls for billions of gallons
of ethanol each year.
There are some problems with this. The most important is that
people eat corn. More specifically, poor people depend on corn
as a staple. The ethanol market can increase demand, which tends
to increase prices. This makes it harder for many people to
afford food.
There's another way to make ethanol, however -- and it's a much
better way. All plant matter on earth contains a substance
called cellulose. As you might remember from your chemistry
classes, words ending in -ose are sugars, and any sugar can be
fermented into ethanol.
Breaking down the cell wall to access that cellulose has been
tricky, but the process -- driven by specially engineered
enzymes -- is ready for prime time. And not a moment too soon,
either. Federal timetables originally mandated the production of
100 million gallons of cellulosic ethanol in 2010.
But we're not quite ready for that. The technology is ready, but
the actual cellulosic ethanol production facilities haven't been
built yet. There are a few pilot plants around the United
States, and in other countries, but there's nowhere near enough
capacity to turn out 100 million gallons, let alone the 16
billion gallons the federal timetable mandates for 2022.
So Team Obama, when it became clear they were too far out to
kick a field goal, simply moved the uprights closer. Instead of
100 million gallons of production, the revised timetable called
for only 6.5 million gallons of ethanol. My take on this: The
administration, which has yet to engineer a major policy win,
would like to knock the environmental ball out of the park. So
it lowered the target -- knowing no one would notice -- so that
when they approved the plants that could achieve the new output
target, they'd have something to take credit for.
And, not to gloat, but that's exactly what happened today.
The U.S. Department of Agriculture guarantee for a
commercial-scale cellulosic ethanol plant to be built in
Georgia.
The $80 million loan
guarantee will help finance a plant with 20
million gallons in annual capacity. That's more than three times
the 2010 output target. This one plant alone gives the president
the chance to say he delivered +300% more than was expected.
I don't think he's not going to stop there.
I don't think there's any chance of it. In fact, I wouldn't be
surprised at all if the administration is secretly aiming for
the 100 million gallon number it revised. I have two reasons for
saying this: The first is that the Department of Agriculture
said it would co-sign this note before Bush even left office.
Second, there are plenty of other
cellulosic ethanol plants in the works, from facilities that
will use corn cobs and other agricultural waste to those that
will derive fuel from heretofore untapped resources like waste
paper.
Now, many of these plants, alas, are private ventures. There's
no way for investors to profit. But investors can get in on at
least one plant, to be built in Florida, which is poised to
deliver serious results to its shareholders.
That company is Verenium (Nasdaq: VRNM), which built the
nation's first demonstration-scale cellulosic ethanol plant in
Jennings, La., in 2008. Verenium is the leader in the enzymes
that are crucial to the cellulosic ethanol fermentation process.
(It also has a host of other enzymes, including one that
"degums" the world's largest soybean processing plant, in
Argentina.) The company, for its part, expects to break ground
this year. The actual date is unknown.
So what's the holdup? It's not expertise: Verenium is an
industry leader in enzymes and it has wisely partnered up with
BP Plc (NYSE: BP) to construct the plant. No one has
commercial-scale chemical expertise like the major oil
companies, and BP just extended its
partnership with Verenium
and will deploy its expertise as soon as one last thing
transpires.
That one thing? It's a federal loan guarantee. BP and Verenium
are financing the plant and its lenders have sought a federal
loan guarantee on the project. This clearly has nothing to do
with money -- BP's latest filing showed $67.7 billion in current
assets on its balance sheet -- it's about the output quotas. All
parties involved want to be sure that if they devote the not
insignificant resources to building these plants there will be
markets for the ethanol they produce.
The federal loan guarantee -- just like the one issued today by
the Department of Agriculture for Range Fuels' Georgia plant --
is the best way for the federal government to clarify its
intentions. You see, a loan guarantee doesn’t cost a dime. Uncle
Sam isn't writing a check, he's co-signing the credit
application. If the market Washington promised dries up, then
Washington is on the hook to compensate the investors who risked
their money to supply a market lawmakers created.
That's not likely. What's far more likely, and, as I predicted a
month ago, is that Team Obama will point to the success of the
cellulosic ethanol loan guarantees as a way to strengthen the
economy, create jobs and reduce our dependence on foreign oil.
That's an excellent political move from a White House that
severely needs a win. Truth be told, it's not terrible policy.
And the steps to exceed the output quota and build more plants
are utterly fantastic news for Verenium shareholders, who could
well see the value of their stock rise to match the dramatic
+24,515% increase in cellulosic output that federal law calls
for between now and 2022.
-- Andy Obermueller
Chief Investment Strategist
Government-Driven Investing |